Election season is mercifully over, so now we can look to see if there are some lessons to be learned. Whether you are a TV watcher, social media junkie, website wanderer, or old-school radio devotee, your eyes and/or ears were inundated by fear and loathing paid for by your local (or national) candidate or political action committee. But here’s a question: do these negative ads really work, or are those pulling the strings just afraid to try anything else? After a resounding win for those predominantly arguing “kitchen table” issues rather than “culture war,” we may have some takeaways.
It is “low hanging fruit” to turn up with 800 words of complaint and longing for some sort of “good ole’ days” that none of us really remember. Instead, I want to raise the question of the messaging, and whether it is working or just the only game in town.
Anyone paying attention can see there are two types of political ads: the warm, fuzzy, candidate bio piece telling you what a great person they are, the issues they champion, and why you should vote for them. These are certainly the ideal. Make it about you, and if you are the best choice people will vote for you.
But at some point in the media age (I won’t even say modern media) someone decided that scaring the daylights out of voters was the best way to get them to vote, if not for you, at least against the other candidate. Lyndon Johnson’s “Daisy” ad from 1964 shows this is not new. “Vote for Barry Goldwater and the cute little girl with the freckles is going to die in a nuclear explosion!” That was the message. Johnson won.
In the sixty-plus years since, political agencies have mastered the art to a point of it being repetitive, predictable, and somewhat generic. Over a period of a week during the cycle, I spent time in Missouri and Tennessee, my wife was in Texas, and I listened to a football game on a Michigan radio station. The ads were nearly identical. Republican candidate accuses Democrat of supporting transgender men competing in women’s sports. Democrat has Republican in the pockets of the health insurance companies as he votes to make you sicker. Then there are the tailored, personal attacks based on the local races.
The difference this year on the side that dominated was a large number of candidates taking aim at the voters’ financial conditions rather than basic attacks. It was James Carville who said, “It’s the economy, stupid!” That was definitely the message in play for democrats.
Part of the reason it all looks so similar is because it’s all coming from the same places. Political advertising shops in Washington, DC and a few other select major markets are running most of the campaign advertising in the election cycle, all the way down to many local races. All you have to do is pull the campaign finance records for a candidate or issue group and you will see where they are spending their money. If you live in Missouri, most of it is not here.
Of course we can’t ignore the research that is out there. Another part of the reason for negative ads is that past political-science research finds that negative political advertising was more effective. Numbers ranging from 39% to 69% have been thrown around when compared to positive advertising in persuasive effect. That depends on whether advertising exposure was measured over a two- or four-week period. And, in a randomized election field experiment, voters receiving negative campaign messages were 3.8 percentage points more likely to turn out to vote than voters receiving positive messages. Even with this number, though, I would still push back on one question: How far is too far? When does the negative message become so “over-the-top” that voters are offended by it or even laughing at it? I saw a commercial one night saying a Democratic candidate is a “dangerous socialist” who “wants gender mutilating procedures for minors.” Seriously? (I would point out that the “dangerous socialist” won a seat that had been held by republicans for 14 years.)
So, you have a concentrated group of companies that are doing most of the messaging, and you have a style of attack that, to some degree or another, everyone is using. My question is this: Is the over-the-top attack ad actually working, or are the companies doing the advertising simply scared that if they do something different, they might lose? If they did lose, would it be because they didn’t attack, or maybe just because they had an inferior candidate or someone running in a district where they were simply outnumbered by members of the other party?
There is no simple answer to this question, because no one seems to be taking a chance on trying it. I admit, I don’t have the research to tell you how many “up the ballot” candidates are using firms in their home states, but I am guessing they are few and far between.
I also don’t have the resources to do focus group research that many of these D.C. agencies are certainly running. After all, someone is telling them that a segment of the voting populace is being kept up at night by the possibility of their tax dollars paying for a thirteen-year-old to get a sex change or the concern that their local politician is pedophile-protecting buddy of Jeffrey Epstien.
What I do have, however, is the common sense to know that most of these ads are a complete insult to your intelligence and mine. Do they really think we are buying this garbage?
I still want to believe that American voters are more than capable of receiving a passionate, yet intelligent version of why they should vote for a candidate and then act on real facts. I want to believe they have the ability to determine what issues really impact their day-to-day lives and which ones don’t. My desire is to believe that, as a group, voters are not nearly as stupid as present-day political advertising seems to think they are. The results from earlier this month may offer confirmation of this.
Don’t get me wrong. If there is a legitimate reason to attack, go for it. Gas prices and soaring property taxes are absolutely fair game. Just spare me the trip through the political haunted house.
Here at Chemistry PR and Multimedia, we have done some work for local level candidate and issue-oriented ballot initiatives. We have based our work on telling a good story and telling voters why supporting the issue or candidate we represent is in their best interest. What’s in it for them?
Do we have a perfect record? No. Nobody does. But at least when someone takes in something we have produced, they will feel like we made a good argument and didn’t insult their intelligence. And our conscious is clear!
I believe that as voters, no matter our political stripe, we should start holding candidates and the agencies they hire to the same standard. Maybe they will try something novel and begin producing ads that inform. Who knows? It might just work. Time will tell if the 2026 midterms were a blip on the screen or a lesson learned.

